Best Places to Buy a Used Car in 2025 – Online & Local Options Compared

Discover the most reliable online and local platforms to buy a used car in 2025. Compare top options and save money.

Best Places to Buy a Used Car in 2025 – Online & Local Options Compared

Why Buying a Used Car in 2025 Is a Smart Choice

Lower Costs and Better Value

Used cars offer significant savings compared to new vehicles, and depreciation is much slower. In 2025, modern used cars are more reliable and come with better warranties than ever before.

Greater Inventory Options

With online platforms booming and dealerships expanding, finding a quality used car with desired specs is easier than ever.

Eco-Friendly Impact

Buying used reduces the need for new manufacturing, making it a greener option for environmentally conscious consumers.

Top Online Platforms to Buy Used Cars

Carvana

Known for its vending machine-style pick-up and seamless online purchase process, Carvana offers a 7-day return policy and financing options.

CarMax

CarMax is a long-standing favorite due to its no-haggle pricing and certified pre-owned selection. They also offer a 24-hour test drive program.

Vroom

Vroom specializes in delivering used vehicles to your door, with a 90-day limited warranty and easy trade-in options.

Shift

Operating in select U.S. cities, Shift allows customers to test drive at home and complete the entire transaction digitally.

Autotrader

A massive marketplace with listings from private sellers and dealerships. Great filtering tools and pricing guides.

Best Local Options to Buy Used Cars

Certified Dealerships

Manufacturer-affiliated dealerships provide certified pre-owned (CPO) cars that pass rigorous inspections and often come with extended warranties.

Independent Used Car Lots

More flexible pricing and a wider variety of older models, but make sure to do your due diligence and request vehicle history reports.

Franchise Dealerships

Although typically focused on new cars, many also have high-quality trade-ins and lease returns for sale.

Rental Car Companies

Companies like Enterprise and Hertz offer used vehicles at competitive prices, often with complete service histories.

Local Classifieds and Facebook Marketplace

Buying directly from owners can save money, but comes with risks. Always meet in public, check paperwork, and consider a mechanic’s inspection.

What to Look for in a Used Car Seller

Transparency and Documentation

Look for sellers who provide CARFAX or AutoCheck reports, maintenance records, and vehicle history.

Return Policy or Warranty

A reputable platform or dealership usually offers at least a short-term return policy or warranty coverage.

Customer Reviews and Ratings

Check third-party review sites like Trustpilot or BBB to see other buyers’ experiences.

How to Get the Best Deal on a Used Car

Compare Prices Across Platforms

Use multiple websites and local dealers to get a clear sense of fair pricing for the vehicle you want.

Negotiate Smartly

Even if the price seems fixed, many dealerships are open to minor price reductions or add-on incentives.

Check Financing Options

Some platforms offer in-house financing, but it’s wise to get pre-approved from your bank or credit union for better rates.

Time Your Purchase

End-of-month or end-of-quarter deals can yield bigger discounts as salespeople try to hit quotas.

Used Car Scams to Avoid in 2025

Title Washing

Some sellers illegally re-register vehicles in different states to hide salvage titles.

Odometer Fraud

Digital odometers can still be rolled back. Check mileage history via CARFAX.

Non-Disclosure of Major Damage

Always inspect the car thoroughly or hire a professional to do so.

Should You Buy Online or Locally?

Online Pros

Convenience, broader inventory, no-pressure buying, often comes with a return policy.

Online Cons

Lack of in-person inspection before purchase unless test drive options are offered.

Local Pros

You can inspect and test drive before buying, immediate ownership.

Local Cons

Potentially limited inventory, higher pressure sales tactics.

Final Thoughts: Make an Informed Decision in 2025

Whether you choose an online platform or local dealership, being informed and thorough will help you secure a reliable used car at the best price. With more tools and platforms than ever, 2025 is a great time to buy used.